Horns247 Board

Good question. I think Doege could do some damage in our system with a big time running game behind him. Klein is a tough SOB but I'm not completely sold on him. Gun to my head, I'd go with Smith or Doege probably.

I don't know what you guys are talking about, I wouldn't trade Ash for any QB in the Big 12

Gonna go against the grain and say pachall. I was really impressed with how he went throw for throw with RGIII. Its easy to get demoralized when that offense is putting up monster numbers but he kept battling.

With our defense an running game, I'd take Klein in a heartbeat

Geno Smith. I think he would be great in this offense and the type of player Harsin has started recruiting at QB. Jones is a system QB to me. And he likes to make mistakes or fail to show up when it counts.

I'm gonna stick with Ash. He's working hard. I think he's going to surprise.

I am fine with Ash. He's got the most room for improvement, had the most working against him, and has plenty of the tools.

I watched Smith plenty last year. He's fine, which makes him gloriously overrated at this point. The guy is going to have problems in the Big 12.

Klein is tough. His arm is mediocre. Meh.

Landry Jones is a running joke. People talk of him as a top 5 pick next year and I'm curious if they've ever actually watched him play. His meltdown in the second half of last year was epic for a JR QB.

Doege, bleh. Paschall, ummm, wow.

If I had a gun to my head and had to take someone other than Ash, it would be Florence in this offense.

Let me clarify, If I had to I would trade for Paschall. Would much rather stick with Ash and ride it out cuz I think hell be better this year and beyond.

Wes Lunt

i'll keep Ash

Love the Deoge comment. I do not think people realize the type of season he had. He had the 3rd highest rating of any QB in the Big 12. I think he threw a pick every 60 passes. Compare his numbers to Jones and you will be amazed. Plus he didn't get to play the Tech defense

Geno hands down